stuffed and starved logo
Only Intellectuals Love Poverty

 

Only Intellectuals Love Poverty

slow food logo

I've been having a fine exchange with Eric Holt-Gimenez at Food First about Slow Food. Slow Food is an idea about which I'm a little ambivalent. It was founded on some fairly important political principles, particularly around the politics of taste. Slow Food's founding question: 'why can't the masses have pleasure when they eat, why is it only the rich who can afford to eat well'?

The response was to observe that workers need two things to bring this kind of pleasure within reach - time and money. So they organised, working with unions to increase agricultural labourers' wages, and fighting for a two-hour lunch break in which to enjoy food.

Now, as Eric notes, Slow Food has increasingly become a circle jerk of olive oil and blue cheese fantasists, moving away quite sharply from its political roots. But in my travels I've met many people who still hold those principles dear, and who are organisers in the best sense.

And I think there's something valuable and vital about the pleasure principle. Emma Goldman has a place on every Berkeley bumper with her line "If I can't dance, I don't want to join your revolution". The idea that there could be profound social change without fun, joy, and sensuousness was as rebarbative to her as it is to me.

One could take the line that this concern is a particularly bourgeois one, and that pleasure won't put bread in the mouths of the hungry. But remember that the need for both bread and roses was first articulated by women textile workers, not by some bloke with his nose in a glass of Pinot.

This, I think, is the sentiment that I find most valuable in Slow Food, and even though I agree with many of the critiques of Slow Food, ably rehearsed here by Meghan Holmes, I think that activists, particularly middle class ones, rate the need for pleasure rather less than they should. To quote a line reportedly from a Brazilian samba: "Only intellectuals love poverty. Poor people love luxury".

Raj's blog | login to post comments

| | |


Posted on 25 February, 2008 - 20:16

Submitted by replica watches (not verified) on 27 November, 2009 - 03:23.
Submitted by girlteam (not verified) on 29 September, 2009 - 11:35.

If you buy Swiss replica Panerai Replica from a credible store, you need not worry about its durability.

Submitted by watches (not verified) on 16 September, 2009 - 08:21.

replica watches

Discount Watches, Fashion Watches, Wristwatch, Fake Watch, Wholesale Watches, Jewelry Watches, Replica Jewelry Watches. Functions on watches include calendars, time zones, stop watches, and alarms. Many have the option of being Replica Girard Perregaux set to standard or military time. Still others have indigo lights that when a button is pressed will light up and replica watches make the numbers more visible. This is especially good in a hospital or nursing home setting where you need the light to read the second hand replica watches while checking pulses. There are some watches IWC Mens Watches that have removable face plates so that you can have your watch match what you are wearing. The shape of a watch can be almost any shape as well such a round or rectangular. There are ring watches and pendant watches. Pocket watches are making a come back as well.
The Rolex Watch bands on Roger Dubuis Replica watches are as varied in material and design as the watches themselves. There are metal bands that stretch, there are bands made of material similar to the straps on backpacks and that fasten with Velcro. There are bands of cloth, hemp, metal links and bands that come in one Piaget Mens Watches or two pieces.

Submitted by Angela C (not verified) on 27 February, 2008 - 03:40.

Pleasure is emphemeral, but political issues linger for a long time. It has been the Slow Food festival here in Melbourne for the past week and I have been to a number of political sessions. They brought Percy Schmeiser out from Canada to talk about his ongoing court battle with Monsanto, we heard from Helena Norberg-Hodge on food issues in the developing world and the problem of food miles, and we heard from Greg Critser on the politics of obesity in the US.

They are also running a series of documentaries, most of which are politically oriented. I saw The Future of Food one night, which discusses the issues of GE crops and there have been many other interesting movies.

The politics and ethics of food and the availability of decent food for all is very important and I commend the Slow Foodies for taking these issues on board and providing forums to discuss them.